Elk M1 UPB Gold Kit

Buddy

Cocooner

Posted 27 December 2012 – 09:16 PM

Hi everybody,

Elk M1 UPB Gold Kit, elkproducts.com, cocoontech.com, I recently installed an Elk M1 gold kit home automation, lighting control, UPB Elk M1, Elk M1 UPB PIM, UPB CIM, UPB phase coupler, Simply Automated UPB with an ISY99 that controls various lights inside and outside my home. I plan to add landscape lights but I am wondering if I should use the M1 outputs or simply connect a switch to the landscape transformer and use the ISY to turn on and off the lights. Is their one way that is recommended or does it simply come down to preference? 

 

    #2 Kevin L

    Dedicated Cocooner

    Posted 27 December 2012 – 10:59 PM

    Welcome, Buddy.

    I use z-wave lamp modules inside my landscape transformers, then use HomeSeer to control them. I do have an Elk M1G, but leave that for more of the security duties and HomeSeer for lighting and other automation.

    Kevin 

     

      #3 wuench

      Cocoonut

      Posted 27 December 2012 – 11:13 PM

      I use the Insteon Outdoor module… M1 outputs will work but you have to be careful you don’t go over the amp rating. 
       

        #4 Buddy

        Cocooner

        Posted 27 December 2012 – 11:47 PM

        I do have the insteon outdoor module but not sure i can operate the transformer with that. Im planning to use the transformer intermatic px600. Are you referring to something like Malibu Low Voltage Outdoor 300-Watt Digital Transformer? 
         

          #5 Buddy

          Cocooner

          Posted 27 December 2012 – 11:47 PM

          Thanks for the welcome 
           

            #6 Work2Play

            Cocoonut

            Posted 28 December 2012 – 01:12 AM

            The insteon module would work just fine – it comes down to how you wire the A/C power for the transformer; you can wire it to a cord with a plug and that would plug into the insteon module listed, then plug that into a receptacle. It would’t work for a totally hardwired transformer (for that you’d want an inline appliance module that’s hardwired in).

            Many lighting transformers look like this one:
            Attached File  15pl100azt.jpg   8.68K   43 downloads

            That pigtail power plug is provided specifically so you can put a timer inside the box plugged into that outlet and that little pigtail power plug goes into the timer… with a transformer like that, you can do what I (and probably Kevin L) did which is use that for a UPB or other lighting module instead. However, I looked up the transformer you mentioned, and it does *not* have that option. 

             

              #7 wuench

              Cocoonut

              Posted 28 December 2012 – 09:03 AM

              Yeah, I got the cheapo Malibu’s. Two transformers plugged into two Insteon controllers. You could wire them using inline appliance modules as well. Those are the easiest solutions. A relay based solution on the Elk would be more reliable, transformers are usually a good source of line noise so that may interfere with Insteon. For a relay solution it can be broken out on the AC or DC side of the transformer. Just make sure you do the math, if the Elk outputs aren’t rated high enough you may need an additional relay that is. 

              Edited by wuench, 28 December 2012 – 09:06 AM.

               

                #8 Kevin L

                Dedicated Cocooner

                Posted 28 December 2012 – 09:20 AM

                ‘Work2Play’, on 27 Dec 2012 – 22:19, said:

                That pigtail power plug is provided specifically so you can put a timer inside the box plugged into that outlet and that little pigtail power plug goes into the timer… with a transformer like that, you can do what I (and probably Kevin L) did which is use that for a UPB or other lighting module instead. However, I looked up the transformer you mentioned, and it does *not* have that option.

                That’s exactly what I did. I use HomeManageables HM-LM001 lamp modules.

                Kevin 

                 

                  #9 Buddy

                  Cocooner

                  Posted 28 December 2012 – 10:44 AM

                  I wouldn’t want to use the transformers timer, would rather use the isy. Not sure how the inline module works but ill do some reading to understand it. Thanks for the help I will repost if I have questions and how all goes. :) 
                   

                    #10 Work2Play

                    Cocoonut

                    Posted 28 December 2012 – 11:16 AM

                    Not sure what you mean by “I wouldn’t want to use the transformers timer” – that wasn’t suggested anywhere in the thread. The spot I talked about was a little loop that they made so you could put a timer in the box protected, but what I mentioned was using an appropriate appliance module in there, and NOT a timer. My landscape lights are controlled as part of my UPB system, so by the Elk and Elve; and I can double-tap my patio light switch to trigger the link that turns them on/off.

                    I’m getting the feeling that you’re still totally confused about this whole thing – so why do you feel that the insteon outdoor appliance module wouldn’t work? Do you plan to hardwire your transformer straight to mains power, or will it plug into an outlet somewhere? Honestly, the answer to that question is up to you… so if you wanted to make it automation friendly, you’d make it so it plugs into a receptacle… 

                    If you really feel like you won’t be able to include the very simple appliance module already recommended because you plan to hardwire the mains power completely, then you’ll need to wire this inline with the AC power: http://www.smarthome…ual-Band/p.aspx 

                     

                      #11 gatchel

                      Cocoonut

                      Posted 28 December 2012 – 11:17 AM

                      I have both and there are a few differences.

                      The lights wired through the M1 Relays work flawlessly but have a current limit. You can use the M1 relay to trip another larger relay but that gets cumbersome. Once again they work flawlessly….

                      I also have outdoor rated appliance modules that work pretty well but they are open to the possibility of powerline communications failures due to things being plugged in. For example: I plugged in a battery charger in my garage that was in a surge strip. This affected the operation of 1/2 of my holiday lighting and took some time to figure out what the cause was. Follow me?
                      Either way will work. 

                       

                        #12 Buddy

                        Cocooner

                        Posted 28 December 2012 – 07:16 PM

                        I was under the impression that connecting the transformer to the main power was a more reliable option to avoid interference. This is why I said not sure i can connect the insteon outdoor module.

                        Any transformer suggestions? I would be ok to use an outdoor receptacle to connect my outdoor insteon module. If I plan to run wires of about 80 to 100 feet can that be a problem or should I consider installing another outdoor receptacle? 

                         

                          #13 Work2Play

                          Cocoonut

                          Posted 28 December 2012 – 07:54 PM

                          Whether it’s hardwired or not won’t make much different; people either 1) place their transformer where there’s power or 2) run a power receptacle where the transformer will go. In my case, I did #2 and ran a new dedicated circuit off the breaker panel to the spot in the hard that everything runs back to – I have conduit in-ground from the garage to the back of a seating wall for low voltage, 120, and 240; and that’s where I mounted my spa disconnect (for future use) and 120V for some new receptacles in the yard; I mounted the LV transformer next to that.

                          Voltage drop on LV for your lights is more of a concern than that of mains power – there are simple enough equations that are based on code for what wire you can run what lengths; for LV, if done right, your transformer will likely have a couple terminals with slightly different voltages to account for longer runs and their associated loss. 

                           

                            #14 pete_c

                            Cocoonut

                            Posted 29 December 2012 – 01:42 PM

                            Here initially I went a bit “excessive” with the Landscaping lighting endeavor and automation. I went initially from the malibu transformers to commercial style transformers. I also went from about 5 LV lights to some 10 lighting zones with something like maybe 50-70 LV lamps (or more). I have some zones which are about 250 feet or more from the transformer. They all utilize 12 guage wire.

                            That said I maybe would have considered some sort of indirect high amperage relay switch maybe to be utilized directly with my panel but never really really did this. I guess similiar to why I would probably never connect my landscaping sprinkler system directly to my panel. My preference went to using my automation switches.

                            Initially started also with one 1000 watt multivoltage multitape multiple circuit commercial transformer. It was rated for outdoor use; but my preference was to take it indoors. That said adding the 2nd and 3rd and 4th one was too much for the single circuit such that I needed to add new circuits to the lighting/transformer endeavor.

                            Turning on and off these transformers I used and tried X10, Insteon, UPB and Z-Wave appliance modules. The Insteon and Z-Wave appliance modules just would trip the breakers most of the time. The UPB did a bit better but it would still trip the breaker. The oldest X10 appliance module for whatever reason never tripped the breakers. I ended up with 4 commercial transformers using the old X10 appliance modules on four circuits and they worked fine for a couple of years. I was pushing these old X10 appliance switches though with the 1000 watt commercial landscaping lighting transformers.

                            Attached is a picture of where I was and where I am at today with the LV lighting. I finished my migration from old fashioned 12 VAC LV lighting to all LED lighting this past summer.

                            There is though two more DIN AC/DC transformers now and they are all connected to one UPB 15AMP relay and have been working fine. The footprint is greatly reduced using these DIN transformers. The older commercial style transformers are large and very heavy (with their toroidal transformers).

                            These DIN transformers though will be probably gone by next year after the solar panel configuration is done. 

                            The next project though relating to the landscaping automation is to go to utilizing batteries and solar panels. I have one neighbor that has done that and it is working well for him. Concurrently trying to figure out how to automate this endeavor (maybe wirelessly).

                            Attached Files

                             

                              #15 Buddy

                              Cocooner

                              Posted 01 January 2013 – 03:31 PM

                              I am looking to buy the below low voltage transformer but I am wondering how many amps I need. Is 15 amp enought?

                              900 Watt 12 Volt Pro Multi-Tap Transformer

                               

                              pete_c

                              Cocoonut

                              Posted 01 January 2013 – 04:15 PM

                              The amperage draw will be the higest when you turn it on depending on the 12VAC draw or load.

                              With a direct connection to the circuit and just turning on and off the breaker my basement lighting would flicker. You could also utilize an amp probe and do the same. If you only have a few 12VAC lamps drawing then it will not be an issue. If you go the maximum capacity (900 watts) of the toroidal transformer then the amperage draw will be highest when you turn it on.

                              Even though the variety of appliance switches were rated at XX amps they tended to trip the breakers (my breakers) no matter what (which I could really never figure out). Best to give it a try with some applicance switch (give them all a try; they are relatively inexpensive) rated at XX amps first. As I stated above only the very “old” legacy X10 appliance switch worked for me.

                              Reflecting a bit now on what I wrote; I was trying to do the landscaping lighting automation stuff inexpensively without really spending $100 (or more) per switch per transformer. That said I learned a bit doing similiar with the chandelier lighting (also purchasing a chanelier “lift” and installing it in the attic – expensive and a pita effort as the device weighed more than my garage door opener (think it was around $700 and the labor to install it would have probably been around $300?) and I had to run a separate circuit for it and spending more than $100 for a UPB PCS switch with some big heatsinks on it; then later automating the multiple cans in the kitchen trying to keep the automation switch costs low; then learning that I really did need a high amperage switch for the 8-10 cans or so it was turning on).

                              The if you really don’t want to play around with this stuff is to go with something like a high amperage switch independant of the controling voltage switch or maybe even better would be a 30 AMP load control switch like the attached links. I went to four of what you purchased and four separate switches on four separate circuits and breakers.

                              I used a variety of toroidal transformers and most of them were large with big footprints. (multiple voltage taps and circuits). My favorite was the first one I installed which didn’t have multiple voltages but had multiple circuits each with breakers in a small fooprint box (difficult though to work in). It was the most expensive one though. The last one I installed before going to the LED lighting was one made by Vista lighting (bought one for me and two for my sister).

                              http://q-tran.com/

                              http://www.vistapro….catid=4&typid=7

                              Here are examples of load control switches (just google them really quick here).

                              The first link is a UPB switch, next is Insteon and then Z-wave in no particular order.

                              http://www.homecontr…&category=73338

                              http://www.insteon.n…troller-NO.html

                              http://store.homesee…e-P407C246.aspx 

                               

                                #17 Buddy

                                Cocooner

                                Posted 01 January 2013 – 08:45 PM

                                The plan is to plug the transformer into an insteon recepticle and have my isy99 control the recepticle for the on and off of landscape lights. If I plan to have the lights around my pool area turn on at different time then the lights around my house and at different time then my light that will be located in another area of my backyard do I need multiple transformers that will each be connected into their on recepticle? 
                                 

                                  #18 pete_c

                                  Cocoonut

                                  Posted 01 January 2013 – 08:59 PM

                                  It might be easier to utilize two transformers.

                                  You can maybe use relays to switch the 12VAC outputs of the single transformer.

                                  I’m guessing that someone on the forum might already be doing something similiar.

                                  Each of the low voltage circuits on my old transformers had auto circuit breakers on them similiar to a 120VAC circuit breaker.

                                  I looked at one of the disconnected transformers just now (the Vista and another one that looks just like the VIsta)

                                  There a “jumper” that appears next to the HV side input and I am guessing it is also switching on the HV side via a timer?

                                  One of the very first toroidal landscaping transformers (other than the one I mentioned) that I purchased did have a timer plus a light circuit.

                                  I forgot the wattage on it but it was totally sealed and one day it just quit working and I couldn’t get to the timing circuits because they were sealed in some sort of epoxy (guess too because it was made for use outdoors). I ended up throwing that one into the trash because there was no way for me to get to the timing circuit on it. 

                                   

                                    #19 Work2Play

                                    Cocoonut

                                    Posted 02 January 2013 – 12:27 AM

                                    You got it – your choices are either multiple transformers, or using a big enough one and using relays to switch the zones on/off. If going the relay route, you need to do the calculations to make sure you’re not going over the rated amperage for the relays. 
                                     

                                      #20 Buddy

                                      Cocooner

                                      Posted 02 January 2013 – 04:11 PM

                                      Im not very knowledgable with relays. Where can I read about how a relay works if connected to a transformer and how does the installation get done. Very interested to understand all my options to be able to choose the best one 
                                       

                                        #21 oberkc

                                        Dedicated Cocooner

                                        Posted 03 January 2013 – 07:05 AM

                                        I am surprised nobody has mentioned LED replacement bulbs as an option, rather than going with high-powered relays and such. 

                                        Quote

                                        do I need multiple transformers that will each be connected into their on recepticle?

                                        Yes. By the way, this is how I do it…four transformers controlled by four insteon appliancelincs, using ISY-994. All lighting is LED. All transformers are 50w capacity, none using more than 15 (according to my Killawatt). Wokks great! 

                                         

                                          #22 pete_c

                                          Cocoonut

                                          Posted 03 January 2013 – 08:04 AM

                                          okerkc, mentioned my LV/LED endeavor near the top of the OP stuff….way easier with LED’s and smaller transformers than it “was” with 4 large 1000 watt commercial transformers and all incandescent lighting….started really slow with only 2-3 zones initially coverting them to LEDs a couple of years back…then this summer converting about 12 zones of lighting. IE: the “deck” was using some indirect lighting with 7 watt bayonet style incandescent lamps; found these little .3 watt LEDs which give off as much light as the older ones (1 zone with 12 little lamps on the deck)….also switching now to pure 12VDC LED lamps lately…

                                          BTW neighbor has a separate transformer for his inground pool lighting; but utilized 16/18 guage LV wire…and you can see the end of the line lamps are really dim due to the lower AC voltage on his 100 foot runs….and another separate transformer for the LV lighting in the pool which changes colors (nice little effect)…personally I just have one 12VDC head light looking lamp on one side of the pool which dims but is a whole separate light, circuit et al… 

                                           

                                            #23 JimS

                                            Dedicated Cocooner

                                            Posted 03 January 2013 – 09:14 AM

                                            I would be interested to know specific brand/model/where to buy for LED bulbs people have found to work well and have good life. Also if they are retrofit bulbs running off AC or if they require DC. I think most retrofit bulbs include a rectifier so they can run off of AC but most LED sets use DC. I could do either but currently have AC with some 4W wedge base and some halogen 10W and 20W bi-pin base. I have had some LED bulbs fail fairly quickly so want to get ones that actually give long life. I think much of it is related to poor design and how hot the LEDs get in operation. Would be interesting to get temperatures of various bulbs for comparison.

                                            I found these that seem to have satisfied users:
                                            http://www.amazon.co…ils_o02_s00_i00

                                            This bipin replacement had good reviews but seems to be no longer available – the seller doesn’t have any products listed:
                                            http://www.amazon.co…ils_o01_s00_i00

                                            I have been replacing cheap fixtures with better ones and eliminating the fixture connectors that poke into the side of the main wires. Am using wire nuts with sealant on the new ones. The poke in connectors you get on consumer grade stuff go bad over time due to water leakage and corrosion. 

                                             

                                              #24 wuench

                                              Cocoonut

                                              Posted 03 January 2013 – 09:47 AM

                                              I am using those led lights. They seem to last pretty well, the only issue I have had is they don’t always fit snugly into the Malibu socket base. In the cases where they were loose I wedged a small clip in there to hold them tight to the contacts. I use LED spot replacements too, they are lasting about 2-3 years on average. 
                                               

                                                #25 pete_c

                                                Cocoonut

                                                Posted 03 January 2013 – 10:02 AM

                                                Here I bulk purchased them from China.

                                                That said the costs in bulk for these same designed and probably manufactured LED lights were $2-$4 each.

                                                Mostly they have lasted a long time except for the last batch that I purchased. It was me not paying attention to the design though. Its really difficult to source these as most of the times its a huge number of vendors selling the same type and design of LED with prices which vary tremendously.

                                                The methodology of the sale description though drives the prices ridiculously high considering how much they cost to manufacture. (IE: LED, low power, hours lifetime). IE: taking the price of an old incandescent / halogen LV lamp and multiplying it by the number of hours it’ll work equals the new number for a similiar lighting LED lamp; guess it sells though.

                                                Funny though that last batch of LV LEDs that I purchased that cost $2-$3 each was selling close to $30 each before Christmas here and folks were buying them like candy. 

                                                 

                                                  #26 dgage

                                                  Dedicated Cocooner

                                                  Posted 03 January 2013 – 10:34 AM

                                                  Pete_c – does that mean we can get a bulk purchase going for some LED bulbs? I’ll help coordinate. :) 
                                                   

                                                    #27 oberkc

                                                    Dedicated Cocooner

                                                    Posted 03 January 2013 – 10:45 AM

                                                    I use led bulbs from superbright LED (online). Watch for light color (soft white) and pick the style that matches your fixture. I also am seeing some selection of replacement bulbs at the normal outlets, such as Lowes, HD, etc… The issue that I notice is that light output degrades noticeably in a few years. 

                                                    Quote

                                                    okerkc, mentioned my LV/LED endeavor near the top of the OP stuff….

                                                    I missed that one. Apparently, so did most of the others. Enough, I say, of the relay discussions!

                                                    Quote

                                                    I have been replacing cheap fixtures with better ones and eliminating the fixture connectors that poke into the side of the main wires

                                                    Absolutely! Solder and seal for me. 

                                                     

                                                      #28 pete_c

                                                      Cocoonut

                                                      Posted 03 January 2013 – 11:07 AM

                                                      dgage,

                                                      I just wrote to the companies and asked about the pricing. No need for a group buy as their pricing is very reasonable. Most of them shipped the LED lamps for free. 

                                                      I’m starting to move to pure DC versus AC LED lamps a bit at a time now. 

                                                      Pick some commonly utilized LED lamps and lets see if we can get them even cheapers.

                                                      Here been purchasing them in sets of 12. It doesn’t hurt to give it a try for a bulk purchase.

                                                      The level of business etiquette is at an all time high these days. IE: I had an issue with one particular product and they paid for a return DHL label such that they could examine the product for faults et al after my complaints. Considering the price (cheap) I paid for the product; much effort went in to ensure a quality purchase.

                                                      My LED replacement stuff post is here:

                                                      http://cocoontech.com/forums/topic/22735-landscape-lights/#entry185718

                                                      More stuff is over here:

                                                      http://forums.homese…ad.php?t=151028

                                                      That whole outdoor landscaping and decorative lighting is really big business. My neighbor payed close to $4000 for his outdoor lighting endeavors. (house and landscaping stuff and pool stuff). (funny in a way though that they ran it all to one breaker on the fuse panel and it keeps tripping the breakers when he added his Christmas lighting to the mix). 

                                                       

                                                        #29 dgage

                                                        Dedicated Cocooner

                                                        Posted 03 January 2013 – 08:13 PM

                                                        Thanks for the info Pete. Now if I ever get my kitchen done… 
                                                         

                                                          #30 gatchel

                                                          Cocoonut

                                                          Posted 03 January 2013 – 08:57 PM

                                                          ‘Buddy’, on 02 Jan 2013 – 13:18, said:

                                                          Im not very knowledgable with relays. Where can I read about how a relay works if connected to a transformer and how does the installation get done. Very interested to understand all my options to be able to choose the best one

                                                          Relay overload…

                                                          http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Relay

                                                           

                                                          jmed999

                                                          Dedicated Cocooner

                                                          Posted 10 January 2013 – 07:54 AM

                                                          I use the ISY to control my landscape lights instead of the M1. I also use 3 watt LEDs instead of the OEM 20 watt bulbs. I absolutely love this setup! 
                                                           
                                                          Forum Source: http://cocoontech.com/forums/topic/22735-landscape-lights/

                                                          2 comments on “Elk M1 UPB Gold Kit

                                                          1. cdigatel on said:

                                                            I found Simply Automated is a nice complement to the Elk M1 panel. Just need an interface module, contact Simply Automated for details. Great lighting complement for the Elk M1 panel. I added the Simply Automated relay/appliance module to my landscape lighting transformer, I can now turn on/off my landscape lighting on a schedule, or from a keypad, or flash the exterior lights on alarm… via the M1! Great security enhancement!!

                                                          2. Very good post! We are linking to this great article on our site.
                                                            Keep up the great writing.

                                                          Leave a Reply

                                                          Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

                                                          *

                                                          * Copy This Password *

                                                          * Type Or Paste Password Here *

                                                          You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>